Many people don’t realise that the distinguished journalist and author
Gordon McLauchlan is an inveterate practical joker. His latest wheeze certainly took in the
Herald’s Brian Rudman, whose
column on Friday painted Gordon as the victim of a dastardly conspiracy concocted by the NZ Society of Authors (PEN NZ Inc).
The story starts with a post by Gordon on 3 February on his brother-in-law Graham Beattie’s blog, which billed him as “Former New Zealand Society of Authors (Pen NZ Inc) president and President of Honour”, which could be misinterpreted as implying that he is the current President of Honour and speaks on behalf of the NZSA. His post said that a recent NZSA branch meeting had passed a remit he proposed about trying to have the judges of the Montana Book Awards be more geographically diverse instead of mostly being Wellingtonians. His post goes on to criticise this year’s judges as being too Wellingtonian.
Next, says Rudman:
The wrath of Wellington was swift. In October last year, Mr McLauchlan had agreed to represent the NZSA on the Montana awards management committee. But this week, following publication of the article, Linda Henderson, chair of the book awards management committee and chief executive officer of Booksellers NZ, declared him suddenly unwelcome.
Incredibly, the brave defenders of free speech immediately curled over and said yes, so sorry, we'll find you a poodle instead. On Wednesday, Mr McLauchlan received notice of his sacking from NZSA executive director Liz Allen […]
Oddly, [NZSA president Paul Smith] went out of his way to support Mr McLauchlan’s call for judging changes.
This is where the comedy begins. The “wrath of Wellington” could hardly come from a committee which – as Gordon knows but Rudman clearly doesn’t – has members from around the country. And as Gordon knows but Rudman doesn’t, the NZSA didn’t offer to “find a poodle”, whatever that means. Gordon didn’t “receive notice of his sacking”: he was never appointed, so how could he be sacked? And there is nothing odd in Smith supporting Gordon’s call for changes in how judges are selected – as Gordon knows but Rudman clearly doesn’t, most members of the NZSA do.
Then came Chapter Two, the casting of Gordon as Heroic Victim of a conspiracy. There has been a flurry of apparently sincere emails from him alleging that all this is a conspiracy against him, trying to deny him freedom of speech, all organised by Smith and the society’s executive director, Liz Allen. This is the comedy masterstroke. The idea that Booksellers NZ and the Book Publishers Association, the heavyweights on the Montana committee, do the bidding of the NZSA is hilarious. God, if only it were true – authors would receive better royalties and we’d drive cars that were as flash as our publishers’. Rudman fell for it hook, line and sinker.
And today the Rudman column was posted on
Beattie’s blog with the comment that “this issue is everything to do with freedom of speech”. What’s wonderful about this claim is that Gordon has so far expressed his views not only on the blog but also in the
Herald and on National Radio. Apparently John Campbell on TV3 is next, which would give him the media hat trick.
It’s as far from what goes on in Russia and Saudi Arabia as you could get and if it were intended seriously as a complaint about suppression of free speech, which
PEN is all about, it would be offensive. But it’s all a prank.
On Friday Gordon told another former president: “I take no delight in this and don’t feel much like talking to TV3 this morning, but I guess what needs to be said needs to be said.”
I hate to spoil the joke, but what he told me two days before was: “[I] haven’t had so much fun in months.”